Andy Blake, better known on Tumblr as andythanfiction, is not at all what he seems. Presenting himself as a friendly, enthusiastic, artful member of the supernatural fandom, Andy would appear to be harmless and even comes off as extremely cool and likable. This could not be farther from the truth. Andythanfiction is a harmful, dangerous cult leader. Yes, for real. Cults still exist. I know, I was shocked, as well.
My intent in writing this post is twofold:
- Warn and protect the friends I made at DC Con
- Warn and protect the cast of Supernatural
I met Andythanfiction at the most recent Creation Ent. Supernatural Convention, in Washington DC, where he not only won the cosplay contest for Best Castiel, but also donned an extremely good Kevin Tran cosplay (pictured above) for most if not all of Friday and Sunday. He was delightful. He was impressive. He actually got Mark Sheppard to use props in a photograph. I liked him.
Earlier today, I remembered where I’d heard his name before. It wasn’t, as I’d suspected, from reading his Destiel meta. No. It was something far more sinister.
I remembered reading an article about a man who liked to flit from fandom to fandom, become popular and well liked, and slowly begin to draw in a “posse”. A group of friends. A following. And then proceed to use them, leech them of their money and identity, take what he wanted from them, and when they began to catch wise, dump them out of his “protection” with no money, no friends outside the cult, and no idea of who they were without him.
I thought to myself that it couldn’t have been the Andy I met. And then I checked my blog. Not, as you’ll notice, this blog. And I found the post I’d been thinking of. I will not link it here, as to not endanger the author of the original ask post. They’re a dear friend of mine and the entire point of this post is to keep the people I love safe. But, I will copy the text of it, below.
Anonymous asked: who is that andy guy? what did he do? i never heard of himI included a link in that post — though I’d say it’s probably best that if you haven’t heard of him, not to trouble yourself with reading into it. Unless you like reading about sociopaths and cult leaders. In that case, it might be considered an interesting read.
Suffice it to say he is a well-known destiel meta writer on tumblr and years ago he did some very awful things in another fandom, and I am worried for my own little SPN fandom. I am also vaguely worried about Misha, but I don’t think that one’s a very valid worry. You can read the information in the linked post for more information.
Go on and read the linked post. I’ll wait. While you’re there, feel free to click on the other posts that one links to. Trigger Warning for gaslighting, brainwashing, sexual assault, sexual abuse, cults, and emotional manipulation. If I have forgotten to warn for something, please do message me and I will append this paragraph.
The above post was written in October of 2013. At that point, Andy had not gone to any Supernatural conventions, and was still in the process of assimilating himself into our fanmily.
He has now begun to escalate, as he has done before. At this last convention, he was buddying up to Osric, and telling fans that Osric gave him his phone number. This is yet to be confirmed, but if he has, the situation is even more troubling.
Andy has been working on gaining the trust of not only Osric but of many fans of the show. One way he earns people’s trust is by playing the victim card. He then uses that trust to victimize others. If you doubt that he could, then he has probably gotten to you.
Because he’s likable. He really is. You may read the post above and think, “Wow, what a monster, I bet he’s actually really creepy.”
He is not. He is very good at what he does. If he was noticeably creepy, even to one’s intuition, people would not trust him, and he would not be a threat.
If you met him at the convention a couple of weeks ago, you may already like him. You may already consider him a friend. You may even be going to his Season Nine party, or traveling with him to San Diego con.
Do. Not.
Even if you tell yourself that you do not and will not trust him, do not go near him. Keep. Your. Distance. He will weasel his way past your guard just as soon as you’re not looking. He will find the cracks in your defenses and slip silently in through them and the next thing you know, he’ll be inducting you into his Posse and you’ll be telling yourself that he really isn’t so bad, and then I fear it will be too late for you.
He WILL play the victim. He WILL say that this and all other posts exposing him are unfair and ruining his life. He WILL refuse to own up that he is only ruining his OWN life by continuing to act this way and follow these patterns of behavior. And if he DOES own up it will only be to say that he’s changed now. But do you see how his “friends” call themselves his “posse” now? How he refers to them as a herd?
By the way, none of this is to blame any of his friends. It is extremely important to remember is that they are not foolish people. They’re intelligent, good people. Do not think that by being “smarter” or “more careful” than them that you can avoid the harm that Andy inflicts on the people around him.
The ONLY way to avoid harm is to stay away from him. If you do know him, immediately do everything in your power to cut ALL contact with him.
Spread the word.
THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT AND COMPLETELY LEGIT POST.
Five or six years ago, thanfiction was in Harry Potter fandom. A good friend of mine was abused cruelly by him. She started out as a friend of his, and when she pulled back, his abusive behaviour escalated, to the point where her LJ was completely locked down, and he was using some of her best friends to spy on her private LJ posts which were then reposted and ridiculed by him and his followers. It took her ages to find thanfiction’s moles in her friendslist. I’ve seen some pretty horrific behaviour from people on the internet over the eighteen or so years I’ve been on it, but this was some of the worst.
Another friend of mine commissioned artwork from him for a fest she was running – he took her money, took forever to mail her the work, and when she did receive it, it was pretty much destroyed, inside the packaging. He blamed a friend who he ‘gave the art to to post for him’. My friend never received a refund.
thanfiction also tried to court me as a potential for his clique in this incredibly narcissistic comment on the final chapter of a story it took me a year to write. Luckily, I’d been a victim of abuse, both in real life and on the internet before, and after I shot him down in the politest way I could manage given the self-aggrandising tone of the comment, he never bothered to approach me again. (Had he properly done his homework on me, he would have known that my partner, kath-ballantyne, had been illustrating chapters of my story from the very beginning. While fanart is always a lovely compliment, in this case, it certainly wasn’t the irresistible lure he thought it would be.)
(Converting this to a text post rather than a photo post because I don’t want Andy’s stupid face on my blog.)
Your semi-regular reminder that Andrew Blake is an abusive, narcissistic sociopath who uses other fans and celebrities to further his own agenda.
And, wow the linked comment is just… wtf. “As someone who doesn’t really fancy slash” haha okay dude.
I know, right? You’ll notice that from the very first word, everything he says is about himself. I think what makes it all the more startling is that we’d never had a conversation before this comment. He’d never read or commented on one of my stories. He didn’t even have the ‘cover’ of showing interest as a friend. And he states right at the beginning, ‘I have not read your story and I never will’, and that begs the question. ‘Well, then why are you here? And I know exactly why. Allow me to demonstrate with a short reinterpretation of that comment to be slightly more honest.
Hey there. I see you wrote a story. I wrote a story and it’s big and it’s beautiful and it’s amazing, and I have heaps of people who love me and love it because, well, naturally. I deserve it. So, I notice you’ve got a lot of people reading your story. That’s nice. I want them, because I always need more followers, and they’re obviously misguided if they’re over here, reading your, whatever-it-is, when they could be reading my story and basking in my magnificence.
So, I’m going to offer you something of a present.
I’m going to make a gloriously generous offer that you’d be incredibly rude to turn down because I’m giving you fanart, and everyone loves and appreciates fanart, because fanart is like gold. Better, it’s my fanart, so it’s more like diamonds.
I’m going to make you a piece of fanart for a scene that you choose (awesome, because then you’re happy and I don’t have to read through however many words of your drivel to find something to inspire me). It costs me nothing but a bit of my time, and it’ll have the added bonus (original intention) of linking your dinky little story with ME. Then, every time one of your readers (adorable) looks at your… thing, they get a free advertisement to me! They have to think of me, because I’M THERE, IN YOUR STORY, EVEN THOUGH I HAD NO PART IN MAKING IT AND I HATE SLASH AND WILL NEVER READ IT. And because we’re now inextricably linked, your readers will flow to me and my magnificence like water flowing downhill, and what was yours will be mine – readers, credit for your creation, everything.
This is where you say thankyou. YOU’RE WELCOME.
If anyone reading this reads the original comment and thinks I’m inflating the weight and meaning of the approach thanfiction made, trust me, I am not. What he said and how he said it was CLASSIC GROOMING BEHAVIOUR. Grooming is a term very familiar to those of you out there who have personal or professional experience with child sexual assault. It’s the honeymoon period where an abuser flatters a mark, gives them gifts, tells them how special they are, before they escalate into isolation and assault. It is a very telling behaviour of intent and for those who know how to spot it, it is unmistakeable. Grooming is never about what the abuser can offer a mark, it’s about how they can best make a mark feel indebted to them, the classic ‘I gave you something you wanted, now you have to give me something I want.’ In the case of thanfiction, the only thing I had to offer him was access to the readers following my story. I wasn’t rich, I wasn’t a BNF, I wasn’t in the same country and I wasn’t emotionally or sexually available. So I didn’t take the lure, and I protected my readership as best I could by refusing his advances.
REBLOGGING DEC 2017 FOR CRITICAL ROLE FANDOM
For anyone wanting a refresher or evidence of my past interaction with thanfiction, here you go.


